Suggest a game to do next (a.k.a. Game idea Survivor island, ep. 1)?

[jonne]

Select your contestants for head-to-head immunity challenge

Ok, now READ CAREFULLY

You need to pick 4 (four) contestants for the immunity challenge.

From this challenge:

• 2 best will gain immunity go on to finals
• 2 will be eliminated straight
• Castleboy is not selectable, because per @pharap 's immunity idol, it is already in the finals

So be tactical with your voting, do just not put 4 of your favourites, because 2 will be deleted.

Poll: my 4 choices for the face-to-face challenge are …

• Dungeon crawler
• Shmup (shoot-em-up)
• Wolf3D type game
• Little Pokitto people
• Simple puzzle-y platformer
• Micro Minecraft3D
• Outrun-y driving game
• Multiplayer Bomberman

[sbmrgd]

I don’t fully understand this round. We have still 8 games left of which 2 will go to the finales and 2 will be eliminated, but what happens to the other 4 games?

[jonne]

They are in limbo. What happens to them, only the batcomputer knows.

I voted by taking 2 of my favourites + 2 of my least favourites.

[jonne]

One more voter needed!

[HomineLudens]

The challenge here is becoming understand how to vote

[Vampirics]

There’s now a meta game to the challenges! i kinda like it.

[jonne]

And, we have face-off contestants, they are:

• Shmup (shoot-em-up)
• Little Pokitto people
• Outrun-y driving game
• Multiplayer Bomberman

next phase will start soon (1 hour or so)

[jonne]

Immunity challenge - face-to-face !

This is a 3 part poll

Q1 If I was stranded on a desert island with just one game, i hope it would be a …

• Shmup (shoot-em-up)
• Little Pokitto people
• Outrun-y driving game
• Multiplayer Bomberman

Q2 OMG, I will definitely contribute code/graphics/level design for a …

• Shmup (shoot-em-up)
• Little Pokitto people
• Outrun-y driving game
• Multiplayer Bomberman

Q3 I can totally see in my mind the theme/story for a game that is a…

• Shmup (shoot-em-up)
• Little Pokitto people
• Outrun-y driving game
• Multiplayer Bomberman

[jonne]

Hey! I know this feels like the long march. But, only semifinals and finals left.

Hang in there people ! Don’t lose faith yet!

[Zockeromi]

Woah, i have to catch up (still on work…)

[jonne]

HEY! The latest poll has 3 parts!

… somebody just voted only the first category

And 2 more people did just that again

[Vampirics]

As an admin here, can’t you see who voted and let these people know?

[jonne]

Actually, no. The only way to see it would be to install the Data Explorer plugin and look at the database

[jonne]

Oh come on now!

2 people have not voted properly and we can’t close the poll (or I WILL in a moment, regardless)

Please answer all three questions!

[jonne]

some people didn’t vote on 3 questions

Tough luck.

Here are the results

Shmup : 4 + 1 + 2 = 7
Little Pokitto people: 3 + 1 + 3 = 7
Outrun-y driving game: 2 + 2 + 1 = 5
Multiplayer Bomberman: 1 + 4 + 1 = 6

in a surprise move …

Shmup and Little Pokitto people eliminated Outrun and Multiplayer Bomberman !

[spinal]

Wow! I’m not really a fan of shmups or virtual pets, but if I can help I will

[jonne]

Its not over yet. I will not rest until I have twisted this competition to the point where we agree to make Lemmings

[torbuntu]

I always wanted a virtual pet digimon growing up. But once I finally got the funds by saving up for a year and a half they stopped selling them at the drug store my family went to.

[Vampirics]

I would like to see a lemmings-like game with little Pokittos to replace the lemmings. Then again, a little people game with a pokitto living in a house as a virtual pet sounds fun as well, could almost be turned into a Pokitto SIMS. Anyway… Next wave of voting?

[jonne]

Next round of voting: pscyhed!

“Oops! Did I just say …”

• Shmup (shoot them up)
• Little Pokitto people

“Ofcourse, what I really meant was …”

• Dungeon crawler
• Wolf3D type game
• Simple puzzle-y platformer
• Micro Minecraft3D

VOTE ON BOTH !!!