Suggest a game review template

For now you might as well either put the finishing touches on your profile,
or make a thread in the introduce yourself category.


I presume that means we’re on a confirmed 2/4?

If @Zockeromi up for it, can we make that 3/4?

3 Likes

As i said before, i made another article, i think i won’t find the time to make a review as well…

2 Likes

Ah, ok, I saw you say you made an article,
I didn’t see you say you wouldn’t have time to do any reviews - fair enough.


That means we’re on 2/4.


It might just be a coincidence, but I wouldn’t be surprised if Famitsu chose to have 4 reviewers specifically because of the てんのう (‘shitennou’ - ‘four heavenly monarchs’) in Buddhist tradition.
It’s a common pattern in Japanese media,
most notably seen in Pokemon’s ‘Elite 4’ (literally ‘shitennou’ in the original).

2 Likes

Perhaps Nicole you didn’t look at the format. The reviews per game are very short. A few lines of text and a number

The reason why I’d love to see you as a reviewer is because of your vast experience of games

3 Likes

Did i say i love you all guys? :wink:
But seriously i don’t know if i can find some time atm…

6 Likes

Honestly I myself wouldn’t mind giving the reviews a shot. I’ve been playing games since before I could read. Final Fantasy for the NES is the whole reason I learned to read before starting school. Been experimenting with game development for 17+ years now as well and is the whole entire reason I started learning to program with a good old teach yourself ANSI C 98 (good times were had with bad code when I was but a wee lad).

Just need to know what the final review format decision is then I can put my two cents in for a bunch of games that have been released so far (I’ve played almost all of them so far). Also need to know when the reviews need to be submitted (I would probably type them in a simple text file for simplicity).

8 Likes

You’re hired!

5 Likes

So that brings us to 3/4…


I doubt we’re going to magically have a better artist appear now,
(unless the reviewers want to volunteer to create their own portraits),
so going on the assumption that I’ll be doing the portraits,
can I get a rough guide on how big the portraits should be?

(Preferably in terms of pixels or centimetres.
My scanner can operate at a maximum of 300 dpi if that’s relevant.)

Also, naturally I’m going to need some kind of reference to what I’m supposed to be drawing.

Personally I think the reviewers should be allowed to choose some kind of fictional character to represent themselves if they’d rather.
(Providing it’s an original character of course, or something very generic - being sued wouldn’t be very fun.)
It kind of breaks away from the famitsu homage,
but I can think of a number of valid reasons for prefering it.


Today for practice I doodled @Zockeromi,
so if she approves I could post a scan of that to pass the time.

(I also doodled many many skulls because I couldn’t settle on a style and skulls are strangely difficult.)

1 Like

Of course i approve (what else could i do) :laughing:

4 Likes

You could say “I’d rather you didn’t post it because you didn’t ask permission”,
and then I wouldn’t be able to publish it because I’d be bound by my word.

(Bear in mind the only photo I had to go by was the one on the forum with your chin hiding behind the Pokitto magazine volume 1.)

ZO


And here’s a selection of my preferred skeletons:


(The delay in my reply was because I was ‘cutting them out’.)

4 Likes

:laughing: great! Reminds me of someone…

1 Like

Sent @Pharap a PM with a photo of me and will await the results.

One thought I had for the review section is a brief, “Meet the Reviewers” portion that I’ve seen on occasion in some magazines. It’s usually like a very short interview with some basic questions related to gaming in general with a final question on other interests.

My thought was something like this:

  • Favorite genre and why?
    • Platformers because of the skill needed with precision jumps, and even knowing where to go and what to do there’s still the challenge of execution.
  • Least favorite genre and why?
    • Strategy because I’m not very good at strategy, though I still enjoy a good strategy game it’s just not my go to genre.
  • What do you look for most in a game?
    • I usually care more about gameplay, depth, and story rather then graphics.
  • What’s your favorite game so far for the Pokitto?
    • That’s not an easy question though I’d have to say Celeste Classic, but Legend of Lania definitely has potential.
  • What are your hobby’s outside of games?
    • Mostly I like reading, mountain biking, board games, and painting miniatures.

Score wise I always kind of preferred the out of 5 for these reasons:

  1. Didn’t play it enough to give it a fair score
  2. It really failed hard, but still pretends to be good (really difficult to earn a 1)
  3. It has its moments, but otherwise still needs some work.
  4. Overall not bad, has a few rough edges, but they’re easily forgiven.
  5. Wonderful execution, minor annoyances that are mostly just difference in taste, but otherwise very solid.
  6. Absolutely flawless and there isn’t a single thing I would change or do differently (also should be a very rare score, but to each their own).

Isn’t that skeleton from a cartoon? Pretty sure I saw him somewhere on TV.

@RagingR0nin you should send a picture to @Pharap for the portrait ( I leave that to you since you might not like me picking one for you :stuck_out_tongue:)

I find that rating too harsh, even more for Homebrew games like what we do. Just my opinion though.

Almost reminds me of Grim adventures of Billy and mandy

1 Like

This is definitely true. As I’m going through and playing a bunch of games and giving a quick 2-3 sentence review I’m keeping in mind the target audience (usually the developer) as well as the overall budget of these games (which looks to be an average of $15 USD depending on how much coffee was needed).

1 Like

Most of what I work on is just done to share something decent for free with online friends. And according to my wife, I am giving way too much of my time lol. So harsh review are harder to take in that setting :wink: so a decent margin for rating is welcome I think. So more chances for nuances in reviews if out of 10. But then critique isn’t always easy to deal with but does help people to get better when used correctly.

Unfortunately everyone will have to wait until I can get some feedback on image dimensions.

I don’t mind doing practice runs when I have free time,
but I don’t want to put in effort only to find out I’ve made the images too small.

Seems like a good idea to me.

I agree. 5 just isn’t subtle enough unless you allow going into decimals (e.g. 3.7),
but at that point you may as well go out of 50 or out of 100.


The robe on the two in the top left is indeed the same one Grim wears.

To find a suitable style I looked at various different illustrated skeletons including…

list...
  • Grim
  • Various incarnations of Death from the Discworld series
  • Various skeletal creatures from the Mario series
  • Real human skulls
  • Various other illustrated skulls

Note that I specifically did not look for Sans from Undertale or Jack Skellington from the Nightmare Before Christmas because those are very much not the style I was aiming for.

Grim’s a very good incarnation of the grim reaper:
He’s expressive, iconic and an interesting character in his own right.
(Also, all the fanart done in drastically different art styles is both amusing and useful.)

But he also has features I wanted to stay away from (e.g. square jaw, eyebrows) and some I decided I didn’t like the look of (e.g. cheekbones, nose hole, square fingers, three fingers),
hence the skull is quite different (based more on my icon/logo).

His robe is particularly nice though,
I couldn’t resist ripping that off directly (for the sake of a practice run).
I doubt I’ll be able to come up with a better replacement.
(Maybe I’ll ‘borrow’ a robe from an Elder Scrolls game and see who notices. :P)

1 Like

You nailed it. I instantly thought that was what it was. Well done :smiley:

1 Like

Is there someone in particular in charge of the magazine’s layout?

I don’t mean to be pushy, but I’m pretty much unable to do anything worthwhile until I get an answer about what size the portraits should be.

(I could sit around doodling, but that feels pretty aimless.)